Days of Our Lives Spoilers: Two Abigail Theories That Will Destroy Chad DiMera—Which One Is True?

THE CRYOGENIC CHAMBER MYSTERY THAT’S TEARING FANS APART

TL;DR: Days of Our Lives fans are split over two explosive theories about EJ DiMera’s secret cryogenic chamber. Theory one? Cat Greene is actually Abigail Deveraux with implanted memories. Theory two? EJ is secretly resurrecting Abigail to fix Chad’s broken family. Either way, Chad’s world is about to implode.

The Empty Grave That Started Everything

Let’s talk about the detail everyone keeps forgetting: Chad found Abigail’s grave EMPTY.

In soap opera land, no body means no death. Add in EJ’s mysterious cryogenic lab beneath the hospital, Dr. Rolf’s absolutely insane track record of resurrections, and the DiMera family’s habit of treating death like a minor inconvenience? This isn’t speculation. This is soap opera math, and the equation points to ONE conclusion: Abigail Deveraux is coming back.

The only question tearing fans apart? HOW she comes back.

Does she return as Cat Greene, a woman with no memory of being Chad’s wife? Or does EJ deliver her fully resurrected from his secret chamber, forcing Chad into the most devastating love triangle of his life?

Email [email protected] with your thoughts, theories, rants, or predictions!

Theory One: Cat Greene IS Abigail With Stolen Memories

What if Cat Greene—the woman Chad is falling for RIGHT NOW—is actually Abigail? Not metaphorically. Literally IS Abigail, walking around with Cat Greene’s memories implanted in her brain.

Chad keeps talking about this inexplicable pull toward Cat, this attraction he can’t explain to his family. What if his soul is recognizing his wife even when her mind has no idea who she really is? That’s not romance—that’s TRAGEDY.

Dr. Rolf’s resume includes consciousness transfers (Stefano into Steve Johnson), plastic surgery identity swaps, and enough memory manipulation to make your head spin. Swapping Abigail’s consciousness into Cat’s body would be just another Tuesday for him.

Here’s what has me SPIRALING: this would be the ultimate callback to the John Black/Roman Brady identity crisis from the ’80s. Stefano brainwashed an amnesiac man into believing he was Roman Brady, and when the REAL Roman returned? Absolute chaos. If Days of Our Lives is running that play again with Chad and Abigail, the emotional devastation will be NUCLEAR.

How does Chad process that he’s been falling in love with his own wife, but she doesn’t know she’s his wife? How do you rebuild a marriage when your spouse has zero memory of your children, your life together, your ENTIRE relationship?

And Jennifer and Julie? Imagine their faces when they realize the woman they’ve been condemning for MONTHS is actually their beloved Abigail. The Horton matriarchs have been treating Cat like public enemy number one. If Cat turns out to BE Abigail? The humble pie they’ll have to eat could feed the entire town.

Theory Two: EJ’s Twisted Act of Brotherly Love

But there’s a completely different theory that hits entirely different emotional beats.

What if EJ DiMera is using that cryogenic chamber to bring Abigail back from the dead—for Chad?

EJ’s watching his brother spiral, emotionally destroyed by Abigail’s murder. Chad’s kids are growing up without their mother. The family is broken. So what does a DiMera do when conventional methods fail? They turn to SCIENCE. Illegal, morally questionable, absolutely insane science.

If Abigail’s body was never in that grave—if EJ recovered it before Chad ever looked—then she’s been in that cryogenic chamber this whole time. Preserved. Waiting. While EJ and Dr. Rolf worked on whatever twisted resurrection protocol they’ve been perfecting in that secret lab.

Is it playing God? Absolutely. Should it land someone in prison? Without question. But is it also the ultimate act of brotherly love—giving Chad back the woman he lost, reuniting those kids with their mother?

THAT’S the question dividing fans.

Some see EJ as a hero willing to break every rule to fix his brother’s broken family. Others see him as a villain doing villain things with a convenient excuse. The moral ambiguity is DELICIOUS, and it’s exactly the complicated character work that makes EJ DiMera so compelling on Days of Our Lives.

But here’s where this gets devastating: if Abigail comes back alive, where does that leave Cat?

Chad has FINALLY started moving on. He’s developed genuine feelings for Cat Greene. And just when he’s ready to take a step forward? His dead wife walks back into his life. That’s not a happy ending. That’s a DISASTER.

The Clues Hiding in Plain Sight

Cat Greene has a mysterious, unrevealed memory connected to EJ’s coma treatment in Italy. That’s NOT a throwaway detail. If EJ was conducting experiments during that time—maybe working on Abigail’s preservation—Cat could have witnessed something that ties her directly to whatever’s in that chamber.

Then there’s the 60th anniversary photo shoot that positioned Cat directly between Chad and EJ. That’s the show telling us these three characters are heading toward a collision. Whether Cat is Abigail or whether Abigail returns to disrupt Cat and Chad’s relationship, this love triangle is HAPPENING.

Chad Can’t Win Either Way

No matter which theory proves true, Chad DiMera is facing emotional hell.

In Theory One, the woman he’s attracted to is his wife, but she doesn’t remember him. He’ll watch her struggle with an identity that isn’t hers and somehow rebuild their relationship from zero.

In Theory Two, his dead wife comes back right when he’s finally ready to move forward. He’ll choose between the woman he lost and the woman who helped him heal. Someone’s heart gets shattered no matter what.

Billy Flynn is going to DESTROY us with whatever performances come out of this storyline.

Drop your comments below — what happens next?!

WATCH THIS: