90 Day Fiancé
90 Day Fiance: Andi and Nigel’s timeshare fight splits The Other Way fans over Nigel’s cancel-the-card fix
Andi and Nigel’s timeshare fight on 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way split fans. Here are both cases for who is to blame for the credit card debt.
Andi and Nigel’s timeshare fight finally hit the screen on 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way season 8, and fans cannot agree on who should be paying for it. In episode 7, “Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Family,” which aired Sunday, Nov. 15, Andi told the timeshare story from a tattoo chair. Nigel’s idea for handling the credit card debt set Reddit on fire within hours.
So who owns this mess? Is it Andi, who put the purchase on her own card, or Nigel, whose fix was to cancel that card? The internet has already picked sides, so here are both cases.
What Andi and Nigel Said About the Timeshare on Screen
TLC’s own listing for the episode promised that “Andi finally confronts Nigel,” and the reckoning came while she was getting more work done on a sparrow tattoo. According to Soap Dirt’s recap, Andi said she is still making payments on the timeshare, while Nigel lost interest once it failed to deliver the vacation he wanted.
When the talk turned to the card, Nigel suggested it should have been simple to just cancel it. Andi pushed back that it was not that easy, since closing it would cost her the frequent flyer miles she had built up. Fans quote Nigel’s take on the debt as “One cancelled credit card away from making it disappear,” the title of one of the busiest threads about the episode.
Here is the part the angriest posts leave out. Before the scene ended, Nigel admitted he had let her down on the timeshare and said he would start covering his share of the payments, per the same recap. He also got stuck paying for the tattoo.
Who Is to Blame for Andi’s Timeshare Debt?
The case against Nigel is simple. TV Season and Spoilers reported on Nov. 10 that “Nigel first agreed to split a $10,000 timeshare purchase,” then convinced Andi to put it on her credit card and “left her with the debt.” That is an outlet’s summary, not a bank statement, and neither of them has said on the record how much is still owed.
Reddit did not hold back on his plan. “This thinks you can get out of a time share by canceling a credit card” became the biggest thread, with nearly 800 upvotes and more than 230 comments by Tuesday, Nov. 17. “Just because you cancel the credit card does not cancel the debt,” read the top reply in another thread. Others noted a timeshare is a contract, card or no card.
The case against Andi drew a smaller but loud crowd. A thread titled “Can we just admit that Andi is the problem?” argued that Nigel never forced the purchase and that Andi tells the story as if she had no say in it. “Andi may be a problem, but Nigel can’t be that stupid,” one of its top replies fired back. Another reply summed up plenty of fans: “i think they both suck.”
Why the Timeshare Hit Such a Nerve
TLC’s season bio paints Andi as the planner and Nigel as the laid-back nomad, and this purchase puts that clash on one credit card statement. Yet the two loudest takes online each skip half of the scene.
The “he stuck her with it” crowd rarely mentions that Nigel promised on camera to start paying his share. The “she should have canceled it” crowd skips that Andi’s first objection on screen was losing her miles, not some belief that the balance would vanish. Read the whole scene and the truth looks messier: she swiped, he shrugged, and both of them are now on the hook to fix it.
Where Andi and Nigel Stand Now
As of Nov. 17, neither of them has confirmed a split. Rumors have trailed the pair all fall, from one Redditor’s claim that Andi turned up on Tinder to festival photos of Nigel with Azrael, a woman viewers know from the show. Andi has been promoting music gigs around Nashville, the career TLC says she put on hold to move to Australia.
Will Nigel actually pay his half? TLC has not posted a title or description for episode 8, which airs Sunday, Nov. 22, at 8 p.m. ET, so for now his promise is all anyone has. See our running list of 90 Day Fiance couples still together in 2026.
Whose fault is the timeshare, Andi’s or Nigel’s? Make your case in the comments below.
Catch up on every twist in our 90 Day Fiance coverage.
Nigel’s Promise to Pay Is the Real Test for Andi and Nigel
Our take: Andi said yes, Andi swiped, and Andi owns a piece of this. But a man who answers a shared debt by telling his partner to cancel her card is offering an escape hatch, not a plan, and it took a tattoo chair and a camera crew for Nigel to say he would pay up.
If those payments show up, Nigel earns a little grace. If they don’t, the fans calling him the problem win this one outright. So whose fault is the timeshare? Cast your vote on our Facebook page.
What did you think?
