GH SHOCKER! Maxie Jones Chose Spinelli Over Nathan West and We Already Know She Is Going to Regret It

MAXIE JONES PICKED SPINELLI BUT EVERYTHING SHE SAID AT THAT GRAVE SAYS OTHERWISE ON GH

TL;DR: Maxie Jones chose Spinelli on General Hospital and we are calling it right now: this woman is going to unravel. She stood at Nathan West’s grave, told him she would always love him, and then went home and picked the safer option. The question is not whether Maxie regrets this. The question is what Nathan does next and whether Maxie can survive watching him move on.

Maxie Did Not Say Goodbye

Maxie Jones stood at Nathan West‘s grave on General Hospital and said three words that are going to follow her for the rest of this storyline: I will always love you. Not I loved you. Not I have moved on. Always. Present tense. No expiration date. She told the man she mourned for seven years that her grief over losing him was so consuming it blinded her to Peter August and that reuniting with Spinelli had made her happy. Then she said dragging this out would hurt the children and she had made her choice.

She went home. Spinelli was sitting in the living room clutching a Halloween photo, bracing himself to lose her. She told him he was her home. They kissed. And it was beautiful. But “you are my home” and “I will always love you” are two very different sentences spoken to two very different men on the same night, and Maxie Jones is going to have to live with both of them.

Do you think Maxie made the right choice or is she going to regret letting Nathan go? Send your wildest theory to our editor Amber at [email protected]!

This Is Not a Woman Who Plays It Safe

Here is why we do not buy it. Maxie Jones has never once in her life made the cautious choice. This is the woman who married a stranger, schemed her way through half of Port Charles, threw herself at Nathan West with zero chill, and loved him so recklessly that losing him nearly ended her. Caution is not in her vocabulary. Restraint is not her brand. And yet she stood at that grave, looked at the love of her life who is alive and breathing and standing right in front of her, and chose the comfortable option.

Spinelli is good. Spinelli is safe. Spinelli is the man who would let her walk away rather than watch her stay out of guilt. He deserves the world and we are not disputing that. But Maxie Jones choosing safety over the terrifying, exhilarating unknown of Nathan West is like watching lightning decide to stay inside the cloud. It goes against every single thing we know about this woman. And soap operas do not reward safe choices. They detonate them.

Will Nathan Fight for Her or Let Her Go?

This is the speculation that is keeping us up tonight. Nathan told Maxie he did not want to pressure her. He acknowledged that everything had changed for her while it felt like no time had passed for him. He was gracious and patient and respectful and all of the things that make Nathan West the kind of man women lose sleep over.

But is he going to stay gracious? Nathan West came back from the dead. He has no memory of seven years. The only thing he knows for certain is that he loves Maxie Jones. He walked into that conversation expecting to hear her say she still wanted him because why wouldn’t she? She mourned him for the better part of a decade. She named their daughter after the love story she thought was over. And then she looked him in the eyes and said she was choosing someone else.

If Nathan accepts that and quietly walks away, this story ends. But Nathan West has never been a man who gives up on the people he loves. He fought for Maxie when they first met. He fought to protect her from Peter. He fought his way back from the dead itself. The idea that this man hears “I will always love you but I choose him” and simply nods and moves on is laughable. Nathan is going to fight. Maybe not today. Maybe not this week. But the man is not going to watch Maxie build a life with someone else while the words “I will always love you” are still warm.

Maxie Is Going to Have to Watch Nathan Move On

And here is the twist that is going to absolutely wreck her. Whether Nathan fights for Maxie or whether he eventually turns his attention elsewhere, Maxie has to watch it happen. She released him. She does not get to control what he does next. If he shows up at her door and fights for her, she has to reconcile that with the choice she already made. If he moves on with someone else, she has to smile and pretend the words she said at that grave did not mean exactly what they sounded like.

Maxie Jones told two men she loved them on the same night. She chose one. She released the other. But releasing someone is not the same as being done with them, and every GH fan alive knows that Maxie is about to learn that lesson the hard way.

She said always. And always is going to come calling.

Is Nathan going to fight for Maxie or move on? Sound off and share this with every GH fan you know!

WATCH THIS: Did she make the right choice?

@soapoperamag Maxie made her choice… And, she chose RIGHT! She officially said goodbye to a life with resurrected Nathan, and hello to a future with Spinelli. I'm so happy I darn near cried! #GeneralHospital ♬ original sound – Soap Opera Magazine