Y&R SPICY HOT TAKE! Nate Hastings Cannot Operate and Is Recommending Someone for Chief of Staff and Ellen DeGeneres Called About the Pantsuits

STEPHANIE SIMMONS IS ABOUT TO RUN GENOA CITY MEMORIAL AND THE CHAIN OF EVENTS THAT GOT HER THERE IS ABSOLUTELY UNHINGED

TL;DR: Nate Hastings put Stephanie Simmons up for chief of staff at Genoa City Memorial on The Young and the Restless. Nate cannot operate. Devon Winters broke his wrist after Elena Dawson cheated on Devon with Nate and Nate’s surgical career never recovered. Devon cheated later with Abby Newman and got a bonus baby. Two men. Same cheating energy. Wildly different consequences. Also Stephanie only wears pantsuits. Ellen DeGeneres called and she wants them back.

Let Us Start With Nate and Elena Because That Is Where Everything Broke

There is a version of this story that starts with Nate Hastings putting Stephanie Simmons up for Chief of Staff at Genoa City Memorial and calling it a day. That version is interesting enough. A surgeon who cannot operate recommending someone for the top job at the hospital where he cannot cut. Merely another guy in a suit making personnel decisions above his current pay grade.

But the full version starts with Elena Dawson making a very bad decision that set every single domino in motion.

Elena cheated on Devon Winters with Nate Hastings. Devon was devastated. Devon broke Nate’s wrist. That is the chapter. Clean and complete. Elena cheated. Devon found out. Nate’s surgical career ended on the floor of whatever room Devon’s fury found him in. The wrist healed. The career did not.

Nate Hastings has been merely another guy in a suit ever since.

Are you buying Nate Hastings as the kingmaker of Genoa City Memorial or do you have questions about his standing to recommend anyone for anything? Send your hottest takes to [email protected] and we just might publish them right here on the page!

Then Devon Had His Own Chapter and It Went Differently

Here is where the universe revealed its very specific sense of humor about the men of Genoa City.

Separately and later, Devon Winters had already agreed to be the sperm donor for Abby Newman and Chance Chancellor. Then Devon crossed a line of his own and cheated on Amanda Sinclair with Abby. Devon did not get his wrist broken. Devon did not lose his career. Devon got more entangled with a baby he had already signed up to help create and ended up with Dominic and a whole new set of complications that Genoa City is still sorting out years later.

Two men. Same cheating energy. Wildly different consequences.

Nate cheated and lost the ability to operate. Devon cheated and got a bonus baby on top of a sperm donor situation he had already committed to. The punishment did not fit the crime on either end, and fans on social media have been sitting with that imbalance for a long time.

Eeyore from Winnie the Pooh, in a tailored suit, got a child out of the deal. Nate Hastings got a cast.

Nate Hastings Is Merely Another Guy in a Suit

Let us be very clear about where Nate Hastings currently stands at Genoa City Memorial. He is a surgeon who cannot operate. He has been in a suit ever since Devon broke his wrist attending meetings, looking serious in hallways, and offering opinions that nobody with a functioning wrist asked for.

And now Nate has put Stephanie Simmons up for Chief of Staff. At the hospital, he cannot perform surgery. With the confidence of a man who has apparently forgotten that the reason he cannot operate is sitting somewhere in Genoa City in a tailored suit of his own, having feelings about everything Cane Ashby does.

Fans are asking what standing Nate Hastings has to be recommending anyone for anything at Genoa City Memorial right now. That is a fair question. It is also a question that nobody in that hospital apparently thought to ask before Stephanie Simmons started shopping for her acceptance speech outfit.

Which brings us to the pantsuits.

Ellen DeGeneres Called, and She Wants Her Pantsuits Back

Stephanie Simmons is about to be the Chief of Staff of Genoa City Memorial Hospital. She is also exclusively a pantsuit woman. Every episode. Every scene. Every professional and personal moment. Pantsuits. A rotating collection of pantsuits that suggests either an extremely efficient wardrobe or a very specific costume department directive.

Ellen DeGeneres called. She wants her pantsuits back.

This is not a criticism of Stephanie as a character. This is an observation about a woman who is about to run one of Genoa City’s most important institutions and has apparently decided that the way to command respect in every room she walks into is through the consistent and unwavering application of structured professional suiting.

Respect honesty. The pantsuits are doing their job. Stephanie is getting the top job. The system works.

The Wrist That Changed Everything

Pull back and look at the full picture. Elena cheated on Devon with Nate. Devon broke Nate’s wrist and ended his surgical career. Devon later got a bonus baby out of his own complicated choices. And now the man whose wrist ended everything is sitting in a suit recommending someone for the top job at the hospital where he cannot cut.

Nate Hastings did not plan to become the kingmaker of Genoa City Memorial. He planned to be a surgeon. Elena Dawson and Devon Winters had other ideas, and the wrist that resulted from all of that is the reason Stephanie Simmons is about to run a hospital on The Young and the Restless.

The pantsuits are pressed. The gavel is ready. Genoa City Memorial has a new chief of staff, and the road that got her there starts with a cheating scandal, runs through a broken wrist, takes a detour through a sperm donation, and ends with Ellen DeGeneres on the phone asking for her wardrobe back.

Is Stephanie Simmons the right person to run Genoa City Memorial, or does Nate Hastings have absolutely no standing to recommend anyone for anything? Sound off below because this comment section is about to have very strong opinions!

WATCH THIS: Do we need more Malcolm in Malcolm’s storyline?

@soapoperamag Why Is #MalcolmWinters NOT On Screen During His OWN Transplant Storyline on Y&R?! The man is the whole REASON we're here, and somehow everyone else gets screen time. Hit play because we are FILING a missing persons report! #YR #YoungandtheRestless ♬ original sound – Soap Opera Magazine